Clarence Frank Woytasik

Gunner Position - M4A3 (76)W Medium (Sherman) Tank 

Rank - P.F.C. / Serial # 36271631   

 

9th Armored Division / Combat Command Reserve (CCR/9th) 

2nd Tank Battalion, Company A, 1st Platoon 

Task Force Rose   

Team Pyle

 

KIA as part of Team Pyle combat near Bastogne, Belgium - December 21, 1944

 

Purple Heart 

Presidential Unit Citation

Croix de Guerre with Palm 



 

TIMELINE of key events in the life of Clarence “Kelly” Woytasik and Company “A” of the 2nd Tank Battalion of the 9th Armored Division:

 

 

31 May 1919 - Date of birth. Kelly grew up on the family farm in southeastern Marathon County in Wisconsin - the Township of Franzen, about 25 miles southeast of Wausau, WI.

 

16 September 1940 - the Burke-Wadsworth Act was enacted by U.S. Congress requiring men from 21 to 36 years of age to register with their local draft board. Kelly would have been immediately eligible.

 

15 July 1942 - 9th Armored Division activated at Camp Funston in Fort Riley, KS. The 2nd Cavalry Division (U.S. Horse Cavalry) deactivated and men and equipment were transferred to the 9th Armored Division. The 2nd Armored Regiment split into the 2nd, 14th and 19th Tank Battalion. 

 

3 October 1942 - Kelly’s enlistment date as a draftee and given serial number 36271631. The enlistment city in the official record is Milwaukee, WI. Enlistment would have been followed by 13 to 15 weeks of basic training (his basic training camp is unknown), followed by divisional assignment. The date he was assigned to the 2nd Tank Battalion of the 9th Armored Division in Fort Riley, KS is unknown. But it seems likely it would have been the first month or two of 1943. There was a thorough vetting process with draftees and trainees, and the process continued well after being assigned. So, there was always a chance of reassignment.

 

June 1943 - 9th Armored Division moves via troop train from Fort Riley, KS to Camp Ibis, CA for training in the Mojave desert.

 

October 1943 - 9th Armored Division reorganizes into three Combat Commands.

 

Late October 1943 - 9th Armored Division moves to Camp Polk, LA.

 

Early February 1944 - 2nd Tank Battalion begins Preparation for Overseas Movement (P.O.M.).

 

July 31, 1944 – Clarence Woytasik and Pauline Wisniewski get married at Camp Polk in Louisiana.

 

Early August 1944 - 2nd Tk Bn boards a troop train for Camp Kilmer, NJ.

 

19 August 1944 - 2nd Tk Bn and the rest of the 9th Armored Division board the British ship “HMS Queen Mary” – known as the “Grey Ghost” during its wartime service - for departure. Although records and manifests no longer exist, it would appear that the “Grey Ghost” crossed alone and not part of a convoy. By 1944 there was a diminished threat of enemy U-boat attack and the ship was so fast that U-boat interceptions were rare.

 

27 August 1944 - 2nd Tk Bn and 9th AD arrive at the Firth of Clyde, Scotland and boarded trains at Greenock and proceeded to Tidworth Barracks in Wiltshire near Salisbury, England. 

 

September 1944 - While at Tidworth Barracks, A, B and C companies of 2nd Tank Battalion were issued M4A3(76)W Sherman medium tanks.

 

Late September 1944 - 2nd Tk Bn moves to Dorchester, England to board LSTs to cross over the English Channel to France.

 

2 October 1944 - 2nd Tk arrives at St Marie duMont in France on the Cherbourg peninsula. This is near the site of the Utah Beach landing.

 

13 October 1944 - 2nd Tk Bn proceeds to drive to Verdun via Trun, Dainville, Paris, La Courvise and Bergers.

 

17 October 1944 - 2nd Tk Bn arrives at Verdun.

 

18 October 1944 - 2nd Tk Bn bivouacs at Villers La Chevre, France.

 

19 October 1944 - 2nd Tk Bn crosses into Luxembourg and moves toward Merch, Luxembourg. 9th Armored Division was placed under VIII CORPS RESERVE.

 

24 October 1944 - 2nd Tk Bn leaves Merch, Luxembourg and moves to Scheidgen, Luxembourg. 2nd Tk Bn is now at what is the "front line" in that area and begins engaging in indirect fire missions against the enemy in support of the U.S. 83rd Infantry Division.

 

4 November 1944 - 2nd Tk Bn is ordered to move back to Merch, Luxembourg.

 

10 November 1944 - 2nd Tk Bn is ordered to move to Berg, Luxembourg for what was thought to be the final location for the remainder of the winter.

 

27 November 1944 - 2nd Tk Bn is ordered to move to Scheidgen, Luxembourg. 2nd Tk Bn was now placed under control of Divisional Artillery and provided support via numerous nighttime indirect fire missions.

 

 

THE BATTLE OF THE BULGE begins:

 

Dr. Reichelt’s map from “Phantom Nine” covers the dispositions of the 9th Armored Division from Dec 15th thru the 23rd:

 

 

 

15 December 1944 - 2nd Tank Battalion placed under control of COMBAT COMMAND RESERVE of the 9th Armored Division whereupon they move from Scheidgen, Luxembourg to Trois Vierges (54 miles apart), Luxembourg. On the night of the 15th they begin receiving incoming German artillery fire - their first significant enemy fire. Orders were then received that they would be in support of the 28th Infantry Division in the event that they were attacked.

 

***

 

08:00 17 December 1944 - 2nd Tank Battalion was no longer to fight as a unit - its companies were deployed to different locations. At 0800 “B” Company is ordered to proceed to Dummage, Luxembourg, and at 1000 is ordered to proceed to Clervaux and report to the C.O. of the 110th Infantry Regiment of the 28th Infantry Division. “B” company’s 3 platoons split up into separate missions around Clervaux.

 

12:00 17 December 1944 - 2nd Tk Bn less Companies “B” and “Service” ordered to assemble and prepare a defensive position at Wilmerdange, Luxembourg.

 

17:00 17 December 1944 - Last message received from “B” Company of 2nd Tank Battalion. All “B” company tanks are lost in the determined American resistance around Clervaux.

 

17:25 17 December 1944 - Companies “A”, “C” and “D” of 2nd Tk Bn move to Oberwampach, Luxembourg - arriving at 0100 18 December 1944.

 

***

 

01:00 18 December 1944 - TASK FORCE ROSE - Company “A” of 2nd Tk Bn along with Company “C” of the 52nd Armored Infantry Battalion move up to a defensive position at Antoniushof - one platoon of infantry each covering the approach from Asselborn to the north and Clervaux to the east. Infantry was placed 300 yards in front of the three tank platoons of Co A 2nd Tk. The 73rd Armored Field Artillery Battalion was ordered to displace their firing batteries to provide artillery support for both the Rose and Harper roadblocks from the near the village of Buret (located nortwest of the roadblocks).

 

08:30 18 December 1944 – The infantry of Task Force Rose fell back to the Co. “A” tanks, reporting that three enemy tanks supported by infantry were approaching.

 

09:00 18 December 1944 - Company “A” fires upon three approaching enemy tanks emerging from the woods just to the north of the Clervaux road. Hits were scored on all three tanks. One enemy tank was knocked out. The other two turned back to the woods. Next, four infantry supported enemy tanks came into view from the woods to the northeast. A few minutes later a full tank column was spotted coming from the north along the Asselborn highway. The tanks turned their machine guns upon the American armored infantry forcing them to retreat to behind the tanks. The approaching column from the north was fired upon and withdrew.

 

10:00 18 December 1944 – the M7 howitzers of the 73rd Armored Field Artillery Battalion assumed their new firing positions near Buret and assisted by engaging in indirect fire upon the enemy positions approaching the roadblock. Enemy artillery briefly shelled the TF Rose position and then proceeded to lay down smoke in front them. The smoke lifted in 15 minutes, but no immediate assault followed.  

 

11:00 18 December 1944 - enemy shelling began again and a smoke screen was laid in front of the positions of TF Rose. After 90 minutes, the smoke cleared and at least 16 tanks of the 2nd Panzer Division had closed to within 800 yards of the tanks of Company “A”. Additional fire was received from ground mount enemy 88s estimated to be 2500 yards distant to the east. In the exchange of fire, three enemy Mark IVs were knocked out, while one of their own was set ablaze, the gun of a second disabled, and a third which threw a track and was destroyed by its crew.

 

12:00 18 December 1944 (and subsequent times indeterminate) –

 

Co. “A” could now hear tanks on its right flank and shifted a platoon to cover that flank whereupon they engaged three more enemy tanks - one of which as destroyed and the other two withdrew into defilade.  One Sherman bogged and had to be evacuated. Once again, the riflemen of the 52nd AIB were forced with withdraw behind the tanks again while being raked by enemy machine gun fire.

 

With the bulk of TF Rose facing east now, and only one tank platoon left to defend the north flank, the enemy moved units toward that position to initiate an attack. TF Rose was nearly surrounded and about to be destroyed.

 

Co. “A” commander Lt. De Roche was ordered to lead his tanks out of their encirclement to the west and then south and resume their attack upon the enemy astride the road to Bastogne. TF Rose soon occupied a new position near Wincrange and once more impeded enemy movement along the road to Bastogne. In yet another exchange of fire, two more enemy Mark IVs were set ablaze.

 

As darkness now approached (perhaps around 4PM on December 18th) the enemy initiated a heavy white phosphorous barrage, necessitating the tanks to stay buttoned up. Lt. De Roche then withdrew his tanks to behind a ridge south of Wincrange. During this time the tankers could hear enemy tanks to their right and rear, in addition to their front.

 

At last Lt. De Roche was given permission by Major Dalton to withdraw to the NE, toward Troine.

 

As can be seen in my correspondences with him, Lt. De Roche managed to extricate his tank company from complete annihilation. And if you are keeping count, it would appear that at least 7 enemy (presumably Mark IV) tanks were destroyed.

 

Meanwhile, down the road near Allerborn, Task Force Harper was overrun by the enemy. If it were not for Patton’s Combat Command “B” of the 10th Armored Division and Team Cherry coming from Bastogne to Longvilly, the road to Bastogne would have been clear for the 2nd Panzer Division tanks. As it was, Team Cherry and the remnants of CCR/9AD suffered horrendous losses between Longvilly and Magaret.

 

***

 

00:00 19 December 1944 – according to Lt. De Roche, as he headed on the road toward Troine, on his way to Houffalize, he ran into Lt. Colonel Harper and a few remnants of TF Harper (a platoon of assault guns). Upon reaching Troine, LTC Harper held back five of De Roche’s Sherman tanks to remain with him. With Harper’s action unknown to De Roche, De Roche and Co. “A” continued on to Houffalize where he came upon elements of the 82nd Airborne division. The officer in charge there told De Roche to head south on Hwy 26 to Bastogne for fuel and ammunition. Meanwhile, Harper and his detachment of tanks and assault guns were ambushed at Vissoule and were destroyed. Some survivors were captured and some escaped. Lt. Colonel Harper was killed in this action.

 

04:00 19 December 1944 – Lt. De Roche now had 9 tanks left, including Kelly’s tank in first platoon. After staying in Houffalize for nearly four hours, they set out to Bastogne for fuel and ammunition. When they reached a traffic checkpoint on Hwy 26, they were told instead to go to St. Hubert. At St. Hubert they were able to find fuel, but no ammunition.

 

***

 

20 December 1944 – Lt. De Roche and Co. “A” left St. Hubert and proceeded south to Neufchateau to acquire ammunition. Upon arrival, De Roche found that Captain Walter Meier from CCR was there looking to re-assemble stragglers. De Roche’s 9 M4 tanks were combined with five tanks from “C” company that escaped from TF Harper, along with 16 riflemen from 52nd AIB. Capt. Meier received permission to proceed from Neufchateau back to Bastogne.

 

23:00 20 December 1944 – Capt. Meier along with Lt. De Roche of Co. “A” 2nd Tank Bn., Lt. Sawyer of the C/811th Tk. Destroyers, and Lt. Cartwright of C/9AD Engineers, 14 Sherman and their crew and 16 riflemen proceeded to Bastogne. Under the cover of fog, they proceeded safely to an assembly area at Villeroux. Later that night Captain Howard Pyle, the commanding officer of company “C” of 2nd Tank battalion, arrived at the assembly area with another 60 riflemen of the 52nd AIB. This new force was designated Team PYLE.

 

Just after daylight – 21 December 1944 – Team PYLE sustained an attack by a company of enemy infantry of the 26th Volksgrenadiers. With the assistance of the batteries of the 420th Armored Field Artillery Team PYLE were eventually able to throw back this attack. Two subsequent attacks occurred shortly thereafter. Patrols of tanks and infantry were sent out to reconnoiter along the railroad east and south of Villeroux, and they succeeded in locating strong forces of German infantry along the railroad track and inflicted heavy casualties among them before returning.

 

7:00 - 21 December 1944 – During one of these morning attacks after 7AM, Kelly’s tank commander Sgt. Bisterfeldt was looking through a pair of binoculars. He then passed the binoculars to Kelly, and Kelly was fatally shot by an enemy sniper.

 

 

------------------------

 

Background to "The Battle of The Bulge"

 

In December 1944 Adolph Hitler and his Nazi regime launched the deceptively named operation "Watch on the Rhine" - a large-scale Western Front counteroffensive in an attempt to drive a wedge between the American army in the south and the British and Canadian armies to the north. Their ultimate military aim was to cross the Meuse River, and capture the key seaport of Antwerp, Belgium (see the map below).  The political aim was to create strife in the already strained American-British alliance. Both aims were highly ambitious given the overall strategic situation.

 

The offensive began in the Ardennes Forest in Belgium at 5:30am on the 16th of December, 1944 - with massive German gun and rocket artillery bombardments followed with the typical German blitzkrieg approach of using rapidly moving armored units to attack and exploit the weakest points in the enemy lines and ultimately surround and isolate the enemy.  

 

The main armored attack (“spearhead"), whose ultimate goal was to reach Antwerp, was carried out by the 6th Panzer Army commanded by General Sepp Dietrich. To their south was the 5th Panzer Army commanded by General Hasso von Manteuffel - whose task it was to capture the key towns of St. Vith and Bastogne, while also protecting the 6th Panzer army’s flank. The German 7th and 15th Armies were to protect the 5th and 6th Panzer Army’s respective flanks. St. Vith and Bastogne were at crucial junctures of the road and rail network and vital strategic targets.

 

In all, the German attack was comprised of 30 divisions (and what amounted to 250,000 men) and was one of the largest battles fought in WWII. Casualties on the Allied side approached 80,000 men.

 

The German drive on, and the American defense of, Bastogne Belgium — December 16 - 17, 1944

 

Because of the nature of the terrain in this area—the Ardennes—hilly, wooded, with many significant rivers—the German strategy in the offensive was highly dependent on the use of roads and bridges upon which their armored vehicles could traverse - the more rapid the traversal, in general, the more effective the attack. In particular, the German drive on Bastogne was marked by difficulties in their securing bridges and roads, and combat tended to be focused at key roadblocks, junctions, and bridges. On opening day, the Germans needed to open the bridges across the Our River and secure towns at key road junctions. The road and bridge network were the primary constraints on the speed of the offensive.

 

Facing the Germans on their drive to Bastogne was the U.S. VIII Corps under General Troy H. Middleton. His Corps was comprised of the 14th Cavalry group, the 106th Infantry Division, the 28th Infantry Division, CCR of the 9th Armored Division, and the 4th Infantry Division—all of which were either battle weary from previous battles, were green, or were under strength. This section of the American line was weak and overstretched…and was exactly one of the points the Germans attacked with the most force.

 

During the opening day, Saturday Dec 16th, the Americans of the U.S. 110th Infantry Regiment under Colonel Harley Fuller of the 28th Infantry Division fiercely held the key road junction villages of Hosingen and Marnach against the German 26th Volksgrenadier division, during which time the German armored units were working to get their bridgeheads open at Dasburg and Gemund

 

On December 17th the Germans pressed the attack and were met with strong resistance, but by dawn of December 18th, the Germans had captured Clervaux and Drauffelt — key towns with bridges across the Clerf River.

 

Right behind the 28th Infantry Division, and backing it up, was Combat Command Reserve “CCR" of the 9th Armored Division - commanded by Colonel Joseph H. Gilbreth. Colonel Gilbreth was tasked by General Middleton with forming two roadblocks on the main roads leading into Bastogne from the east—one was located on highway N12, near the village of Lullange and Donnange at a junction now called “Antoniushof", and the other was located three miles southwest near the village of Allerborn at a junction called “Fe'itsch". These locations are clearly depicted on the maps below. Corps command under General Middleton ordered Colonel Gilbreth to "hold at all costs”. In military terms this translates to the unit being “sacrificed" to buy time for other units behind it to form a better defense. 

 

To perform this task Gilbreth formed three Task Forces: Task Force Rose; Task Force Harper; and Task Force Booth.  

 

Task Force Rose commanded by Captain Lawrence K. Rose was comprised of the Company "A" of the 2nd Tank Battalion (Kelly’s unit, commanded by Lt. John E. De Roche), Company C of the 52nd Armored Infantry Battalion, and a platoon of the 9th Armored Engineers. The Antoniushof roadblock was manned by Task Force Rose.

 

Task Force Harper commanded by 2nd Tank Battalion commander Lieutenant Colonel Ralph S. Harper - it was comprised of Company C and part of Company D of the 2nd Tank Battalion, Company B of the 52nd Armored Infantry Battalion and a platoon of Company C of the 9th Armored Engineers. The Fe’itsch roadblock was manned by Task Force Harper.

 

Ironically, both of these roadblock positions were atypical for the Ardennes—they were relatively flat and open, and allowed for long range direct fire. This put the German 88mm anti-tank guns at a significant advantage over the U.S. M4A3 76mm-gunned M4A3 Shermans.

 

 

 

 

 

Here is an excerpt from the narrative of what happened to Company “A” of the 2nd Tank Battalion on December 18 - 20, 1944 from “History of the 2nd Tank Battalion of the 9th Armored Division" written by Colonel Phillip J. Baird (a copy of which was given to me by Co. D member Sam Boese’s wife Barbara in September 1998 at the 2nd Talk Battalion Reunion in Kansas City, MO):

 

[Note some differences in spellings of locations depending on the language used]

 

[Of the 2nd Tank Battalion,] Company "A", together with Company "C" of the 52nd Armored Infantry Battalion was given the mission of defending and holding the Allerborn-Clairvaux rood junction, covering each road. The three platoons of Company "A" were placed in positions covering the approach on the north from Allerborn and the east from Clairvaux. One platoon of infantry went into position covering each of the roads about three hundred yards in front of the tanks. Co. "C", less two platoons, and Co. “B" of the 52nd were given the mission of defending and holding the Allerborn road junction about 5 kilometers south of the Co. "A" 2nd Tank Bn. position.

 

Since the infantry company commander was Captain Rose and the tank company commander was First Lieutenant DeRoche, the ranking officer was put in charge, and the tank-infantry team became Task Force Rose with the mission described above.

 

[It is this section of Baird’s report, as well as Reichelt (“Phantom Nine”), and correspondence with members of Company “A”, as well as actually meeting members of Company “A”, that I wrote the detailed timeline above. While some slight details vary, they are all quite close and quite credible. Unfortunately, there are a number of secondary and tertiary sources that are wildly inaccurate. Cole is one of these sources that gets significant Task Force Rose details incorrect, and from it, inaccuracies are propagated into tertiary sources.]

 

————

 

For peripheral insight on the Task Force Harper roadblock just to the south, here is another portion of “History of the 2nd Tank Battalion of the 9th Armored Division" by Baird:

 

Action of "C" Company, 2nd Tank Battalion, 17-18 December 1944: 

 

After the Battalion had moved from Trois Verges to a road junction approximately 1,000 yards east of Allerborn, the night of 17 December 1944, it was ordered that Company "C", 2nd Tank Battalion, plus "B" Company of the 52nd Armored Infantry Battalion would defend this road junction. These two companies were to form a team and the senior company commander would be the team commanding officer; therefore, Captain Hays of the infantry company was in command. Captain Pyle commanded "C" Company.

 

Due to the fact that the infantry was some miles away, "C' Company, 2nd Tank Battalion sent a platoon about 500 yards north on the north-south road and another deployed near the road junction to defend it until the infantry arrived. There was no enemy action at this point. The infantry company arrived at approximately 0230. At that time Captain Hays took command and hastily deployed his company, leaving the tanks in their same positions. There was no enemy action that night.

 

All during the next day the position was strengthened by constructing dug-in anti-tank guns, tanks moved to better firing positions, and the infantry dug in. The noise of the battle being fought by Company "A", 2nd Tank Battalion up ahead could be heard throughout the day. All in all, approximately fifty stragglers from the 28th Division were stopped by this team as they came back from the fighting ahead and were put in the line with the 52nd Armored Infantry Battalion's Company.

 

These extra units were deployed, and at this time were told to hold the road junction at all costs and to the last man. Only an order by Corps would allow them to withdraw.

 

The enemy started his attack at about 2000 the evening of December 18th, moving an overwhelming force of tanks and infantry in from three directions under cover of a mortar and artillery barrage.

 

The battle was furious, and the position of Team Harper was overrun by 2330. The order was given to fight through the enemy lines back to Longvilly.

 

After the war, it was learned, from a review of German records, and from interviews with former German officers that Col. Lauchert's 2nd Panzer Division attacked the 2nd Tank Battalion's positions on the 18th of December 1944. New tanks in the 2nd Panzer came from the factories of Breslau and contained some of Hitler's new, wonder weapons, the infra-red night-fighting device. This piece of night sighting equipment was used for the very first time during the war at the Allerborn road junction.

 

————

 

[In the superb book “A Time for Trumpets”, the author (a Bulge veteran himself) Charles B. MacDonald describes Captain Rose as deciding “with or without orders to break out to the northwest." Of course, by the time Task Force Rose truly received orders — per the official 2nd Tank Battalion history -- to withdraw, Captain Rose was missing or dead and the Task Force was commanded by Lt. John De Roche. What MacDonald describes as the remnants of Task Force Rose were actually the elements that Lt. Colonel Harper took as Company “A” withdrew toward Houffalize. Unfortunately, very few authors on the drive upon Bastogne portion of the battle give enough credit to Lt. De Roche and few mention him by name. All books, including Cole, used Baird as the primary source - much of which was presumably a post-battle recollection by Lt. De Roche. But from personal correspondence, De Roche dispute some details in Baird.]

 

———-

 

Army historian (and official “Deputy Theater Historian") Dr. Hugh M. Cole — in what is considered the standard U.S. Army historical textbook on the subject — “The Ardennes: The Battle of the Bulge” briefly covered the actions of CCR/9th and specifically 2nd Tank Bn. Company “A” in Chapter XIII "VIII Corps Attempts To Delay the Enemy". This is a rather inaccurate description. Nonetheless, here are some excerpts:

 

Task Force Rose (Capt. L. K. Rose), at the northern roadblock, consisted of a company of Sherman tanks, one armored infantry company, and a platoon of armored engineers. The southern roadblock was manned by Task Force Harper (Lt. Col. Ralph S. Harper), which consisted of the 2d Tank Battalion (-) and two companies of the 52d Armored Infantry Battalion.

 

In midmorning the troops peering out from the ridge where the northern roadblock had been set up saw figures in field gray entering a patch of woods to the east on the Clerf road, the first indication that the enemy had broken through the Clerf defenses. These Germans belonged to the Reconnaissance Battalion of Lauchert's 2d Panzer Division, whose infantry elements at the moment were eradicating the last American defenders in Clerf. Lauchert's two tank battalions, unaffected by the small arms fire sweeping the Clerf streets were close behind the armored cars and half-tracks of the advance guard.

 

Two attempts by the Reconnaissance Battalion to feel out Task Force Rose were beaten back with the help of a battery from the 73d Armored Field Artillery Battalion whose howitzers were close enough to give direct fire at both American roadblocks. About 1100 the first Mark IV's of the 2d Battalion, 3d Panzer Regiment, appeared and under cover of an effective smoke screen advanced to within 800 yards of the Shermans belonging to Company A, 2d Tank Battalion. The Germans dallied, probably waiting for the Panzer Battalion, which finally arrived in the early afternoon, then deployed on the left of the Mark IV's. Taken under direct fire by the enemy tank guns, the American infantry withdrew in the direction of the southern roadblock and Rose's tanks now were surrounded on three sides.

 

[This description of the 73rd’s disposition is entirely incorrect according to official reports and the fact that the firing batteries of the 73rd AFA assumed their positions at Buret by 10:00 and began registration for indirect fire missions in support of the Task Force Rose roadblock. Perhaps this is the result of comingling of the 73rd’s direct fire engagements with the enemy on the subsequent evening.]

 

Colonel Gilbreth, whose combat command was directly attached to VIII Corps and who was charged with the defense of the entry to the Bastogne highway, could not commit his tiny reserve without the approval of the corps commander. A telephone message from Gilbreth to the VIII Corps command post, at 1405, shows the dilemma in all tactical decisions made during these hours when a few troops, tanks, and tank destroyers represented the only forces available to back up the splintering American line.

 

“TF Rose ... is as good as surrounded. ... have counted 16 German tanks there. ... TF is being hit from 3 sides. Recommend that they fight their way out. They could use 2 platoons of A/52d Armd Inf Bn [the last rifle reserve in CCR]-everything else is committed.... Did not commit any of the TDs, will wait until the over-all plan is known. Plan to push TF Rose toward the other roadblock. If the decision is to stay, some units will be sent there to help them out.”

 

The corps commander refused to let Rose move; and even if adequate reinforcement for Task Force Rose had been at hand the hour was too late. A flanking move had driven back the American howitzers, German assault guns saturated the crest position with white phosphorus, and when the Shermans pulled back to the rear slope the panzers simply ringed Rose's company. CCR headquarters got the word at 1430 that the northern roadblock and its defenders had been overrun, but despite the loss of seven Shermans Company A continued to hold. It had been forced back from the road junction, however, and the bulk of the 3d Panzer Regiment was moving out onto the Bastogne highway. The early winter night gave the Americans a chance. Captain Rose broke out cross-country with five tanks and his assault gun platoon, rolling fast without lights through little villages toward Houffalize, near which the detachment was ambushed. A few vehicles and crews broke free and reached Bastogne.

 

[According to De Roche in contemporary correspondence, Capt. Rose was never even present when Task Force Rose assembled at the Antoniushof junction.]

 

[…]

 

[One of Hugh Cole’s endnotes to the chapter is particularly interesting:]

[5] The useful records of the early and confused American reaction east of Bastogne are for the most part those compiled in the combat interviews, shortly after the event, with personnel of the 9th and 10th Armored Divisions. The journals of the 2d Tank Battalion, for example, were destroyed. Most units lost their records and then attempted to compile an AAR from memory. The interviews mentioned above have served as the basis for the description of the Longvilly action in three publications: The Armored School, Armor at Bastogne (1949); Marshall, Bastogne: The Story of the First Eight Days; and Nichols, Impact: The Battle Story of the Tenth Armored Division.

 

[…]

 

 

————

 

 

Again, quoting Colonel Phillip J. Baird's “History of the 2nd Tank Battalion of the 9th Armored Division" (and again note differences in language and spelling of proper nouns)

 

Action of Team Pyle, 20 to 25 December 1944: Team Pyle, commanded by Captain Howard J. Pyle, commander of Company "C", 2nd Tank Battalion was formed at Bastogne, Belgium on the evening of 20 December 1944. It consisted of 14 medium tanks from Company "A" and Company "C" of the 2nd Tank Battalion under command of 1st Lt. John E. De Roche, Commander of Company "A", 2nd Tank Battalion, and sixty infantrymen of the 52nd Armored Infantry Battalion under command of Lt. Adams. In addition, there was the command halftrack of Headquarters, 2nd Tank Battalion and its personnel.

 

This force arrived in Vellereux, Belgium at about 2300, 20 December 1944. Its mission was to attack and withdraw at certain places in the enemy lines to keep the enemy off balance. Definite orders were to be given the next day. Information of the enemy situation was not available at higher headquarters, but a strong defensive position was established for the night. Just after daylight 21 December 1944, Vellereux was attacked by approximately a company of German infantry. This attack was repulsed, and the enemy driven back with an estimated loss of 75 dead and 20 prisoners

 

During the morning two more attacks in similar strength were repulsed and the situation was considered to be well in hand. Patrols of tanks and infantry were sent out to reconnoiter along the railroad east and south of the town, and they succeeded in locating strong forces of German infantry along the railroad track and inflicted heavy casualties among them before returning.

 

At about 1100, Captain Pyle was ordered by the Combat Command Commander, who had arrived at that time, to send one-third of his force north along the road to Senonchamps, then west to stop an enemy column coming east from Sibret. Shortly after this, the remainder of the tanks were sent to follow on this mission.

 

At about 1200, Vellereux with the remainder of Team Pyle defending was subjected to a terrific artillery and mortar barrage which caused heavy casualties in the remainder of the command. The command half-track was lost in this action.

 

[It was likely during these morning attacks against Task Force Pyle on Dec 21st that Uncle Kelly was killed, based on the description given to me in written correspondence from Lt. John De Roche]

 

A platoon of tanks was immediately recalled, and they were employed to cover the withdrawal of the remaining forces from the town and to cover the withdrawal of two 155-mm howitzer battalions which were in position around the town. As orderly withdrawal was made, and the Task Force Pyle was ordered to go into a defensive position about 3,000 yards to the north to protect the position of the 420th Armored Field Artillery Battalion of the 10th Armored Division. Occupation of this position was completed by night- fall.

 

This position was held from the night of 21 December to 24 December 1944. During this time, the enemy attacked from almost all sides. He subjected the area to an almost constant shelling by mortars and medium artillery. Tank crews were forced to stay in their tanks for as long as forty-eight hours at a stretch, urinating in their helmets, and wrapping up in anything available to keep warm during their long watches in vehicles which were lined with a half-inch of frost caused by the severe cold weather. Many had lost their extra clothing in the previous fighting, but what was left was divided with the infantry in their common fight for survival. Although the regular supply of rations had ceased to exist, the scanty reserve of "D" bars, carried in the vehicles was divided with the doughboys. Some machine guns from the tanks were dismounted and given to the infantrymen to build up fire power.

 

Major Watts, 52nd Armored Infantry Battalion arrived 22 December to take command and the force then became Task Force Watts.

 

 

------------

 

1st Lt Robert J PETERSON of the 2nd Platoon, "B” Company, 27th Armored Infantry Bn, 9th Armored Division wrote this in “Battle of the Bulge Memories”:

 

The three combat commands of the 9th Armored Division were in widely separated locations when the Germans attacked on December 16, 1944. As a result, all three were engaged with different German forces and none were under their division control.

 

Combat Command “R” (C.C.R.), commanded by Colonel Joseph Gilbreth, of Columbus, Georgia, had the roughest assignment of the three commands and perhaps of any command in the Battle of the Bulge. Combat Command “R” stood fast and slugged it out against the overwhelming might of the German panzers smashing toward Bastogne. Had it not been for Combat Command “R”, the Nazis would have captured Bastogne before the arrival by truck of the 101st Airborne Division and arrival of Combat Command “B” of the 10th Armored Division.

 

The 9th Armored Division was on the SECRET list and, consequently, its actions were not being reported. The SECRET classification was not removed until January 5, 1945, after the action at Bastogne. Consequently, the 101st Airborne received the credit for the defense and the highly publicized “Nuts” reply by the acting 101st commander to the German demand for surrender.

 

Small CCR task forces from the 2nd Tank Battalion and the 52nd Armored Infantry Battalion took up positions on the road leading to Bastogne from the east. Their missions were to block the road at all costs, and they did so with considerable loss of men and equipment. Many held their position even though wounded and when German tanks rolled around and through them and when the German infantry infiltrated their positions in the darkness.

 

There was no front line. Artillerymen, tankers and engineers fought as doughboys. The 2nd Tank Battalion encountered elements of nine German divisions. The 73rd Armored Field Artillery fought its way out of a trap and continued to keep its guns in action.

 

Three Battalion Commanders Killed. Casualties were heavy. All three of the battalion commanders were lost. CCR was credited with delaying the enemy for 36 to 48 hours east of Bastogne after which its surviving troops managed to fall back into Bastogne. These CCR troops were then employed as a mobile reserve force known as Team SNAFU.

 

Task Force SNAFU became a potent force in the ensuing defense battles. It was organized chiefly as a trouble shooter for the 101st Airborne, operating under a 10 minutes alert, speeding to defend area threatened by German attacks. Bolstered by Armor, SNAFU proved to be an asset in the 101st Airborne defense of Bastogne until it was relieved by an element of the Third Army.

 

CCR was awarded the Presidential Unit Citation for its action in defending Bastogne, the highest award a unit can receive for combat action.

 

Because of the secrecy order on the 9th Armored Division, and the wide separation of its three commands, and the fact the combats commands were not under their division control and faced different attacking German armies, the division did not receive the public attention it deserved. However, commendations came from two Army commander—General Courtney H Hodges and General George S. Patton, Jr. and also from three corps commanders and four divisions commanders.

 

It was not until 55 years later that the Cold War ended, and German records were obtained that the other two combat commands were awarded the Presidential Unit Citation.

 

------------

 

Quoting "The Story of the 9th Armored Division” - a booklet based on a series of "G.I. Stories" published by the Stars & Stripes in Paris in 1944-1945:

 

The third combat command, CC R, commanded by Col. Joseph Gilbreth, Columbus, Ga., perhaps had the roughest assignment of any outfit in the Ardennes. It was CC R that stood and slugged it out against the overwhelming might of the German panzers smashing toward Bastogne. Had it not been for CC R, Nazis would have taken the town before the 101st Airborne Div. arrived there to make its historic stand.

 

Small CC R task forces of tanks from the 2nd Tank Bn. and doughs of the 52nd Armd. Inf. Bn. took up positions along the roads leading to Bastogne from the east. Their mission was to block the roads at all costs. They clung to their positions even when surrounded. Masses of German tanks rolled around them; enemy infantry infiltrated in the darkness.

 

There were no front lines in this melee. Artillerymen, tankers and engineers fought as doughs. The 2nd Tank Bn, encountered elements of nine German divisions. The 73rd Armd. FA Bn. fought its way out of a trap, kept its guns in action.

 

Although casualties were heavy and all three of its battalion commanders lost, CC R was officially credited with delaying the enemy for 36 to 48 hours east of Bastogne. When its surviving forces fell back into Bastogne, CC R was assigned to maintain a mobile reserve known as Task Force Snafu.

 

TF Snafu became a potent force in the ensuing battles. Organized chiefly as a trouble-shooter for the 101st, this unit operated on a 10-minute alert and sped to threatened areas as needed. Bolstered by armor, it proved to be an ace in the hole.

 

CC R received the Presidential Unit Citation for its action at Bastogne.

 

------------

 

Medernach Park in Luxembourg has a memorial dedicated to the 9th Armored Division:

    

Text on the plaque reads:

 

"U.S. 9TH ARMORED DIVISION 

COMMANDER: MAJOR GENERAL JOHN W. LEONARD

IN DEFENSE OF:

LUXEMBOURG: OCT 20-DEC 26, 1944

BELGIUM: DEC 16, 1944-JAN 4, 1945

THE DIVISION'S THREE COMBAT COMMANDS FOUGHT THE ARDENNES BATTLE AS INDEPENDENT, WIDELY SEPARATED UNITS ATTACHED TO OTHER DIVISIONS AND CORPS ON THE 

NORTH, CENTER, AND SOUTH OF THE GERMAN ATTACK, AS SHOWN ON THE ADJACENT PLAQUES

 

HASTILY ORGANIZED FORCES COMPOSED OF COOKS, CLERKS, MECHANICS, AND OTHERS FROM THE HEADQUARTERS OF DIVISIONAL UNITS DEFENDED THE BERG-MERSCH AREA FROM DEC 16 TO 23, AND THEN ESTABLISHED A COUNTER-RECONNAISSANCE SCREEN EXTENDING 50 KILOMETERS NORTHWEST FROM NEUFCHATEAU, BELGIUM. 

THE DIVISION LATER WON FAME AS THE FIRST ALLIED FORCE TO CROSS THE RHINE BY ITS DARING SEIZURE OF THE BRIDGE AT REMAGEN ON MARCH 7, 1945. IT THEN CAPTURED LIMBURG, GIESSEN, WARBURG, ENCIRCLED LEIPZIG AND ENDED ITS COMBAT NEAR KARLSBAD, CZECHOSLOVAKIA ON MAY 8, 1945 

CAMPAIGNS: ARDENNES - RHINELAND - CENTRAL EUROPE

PRESENTED BY THE 9TH ARMORED DIVISION ASSOCIATION, CERCLE D'ETUDE SUR LA BATAILLE DES ARDENNES, AND THE CITIZENS OF MEDERNACH, IN MEMORY OF THOSE OF THE DIVISION WHO DIED IN BATTLE DURING WORLD WAR II.

DEDICATED: MARCH 3, 1985”

 

Text on the plaque to CCR reads:

"COMBAT COMMAND "R"

FROM DEC 16 TO 19, CC "R" DEFENDED ROADBLOCKS ON THE TROIS VIERGES-BASTOGNE HIGHWAY AGAINST GERMAN PANZER AND INFANTRY DIVISIONS. SURROUNDED AND DECIMATED NEAR LONGVILLY, ITS SURVIVORS REACHED BASTOGNE WHERE, AS THE NUCLEUS OF FAMED "TEAM SNAFU". THEY JOINED IN ITS DEFENSE UNTIL RELIEVED ON DEC 31.

BY DELAYING THE GERMAN ADVANCE DURING THE CRITICAL EARLY DAYS OF THE ARDENNES OFFENSIVE, CC "R" GAINED THE TIME NEEDED FOR OTHER U.S. UNITS TO CONCENTRATE AT, AND HOLD, BASTOGNE, FOR WHICH IT WAS AWARDED THE U.S. PRESIDENTIAL UNIT CITATION (ARMY) AND THE BELGIAN CROIX DE GUERRE WITH PALM."

 

————————————

 

 

Copies of Letters of Commendation to 9th/CCR from the 101st Airborne Division and the 10th Armored Division: 

 

 

Sometime in the mid-1970s I remember looking at the wartime in-country letters that my Grandma (Kelly’s older sister) received from Kelly. From the return address on the envelope shown below I was able to determine that he was in the "2nd Tank Battalion”.  After decades of having thought this envelope and the enclosed letter were lost, my mom found them among grandma’s pictures that were collected after her passing away.

 

 

Finally, in the summer of 1998, I managed to locate and correspond with several members of the 2nd Tank Battalion - first by contacting 2nd Tk. Bn. reunion coordinator Barb Boese - whose husband was from “D” Company. She pointed me to members of Company “A", including Company “A” commander Lt. John De Roche and Uncle Kelly’s tank commander and friend Sgt. Alex Bisterfeldt. I corresponded with them via written letters. I also corresponded with Paul Campbell and James Bradley - both of whom knew and served with Uncle Kelly at points previous to him being killed. Despite a lifetime of studying WWII and the “Battle of the Bulge” it was not until further study did I realize the true importance of the combat in which Kelly’s unit — Company “A” attached to the CCR/9th — participated (as outlined above). 

 

Both Lt. De Roche and Sgt. Bisterfeldt sent me written letters describing their remembrances. 

 

Here is the first letter I received from Kelly’s tank commander Sgt. Alex Bisterfeldt:

 

Here is the letter I received from 2nd Tank Battalion’s Company “A” commanding officer Lt. John De Roche:

 

In addition, I received very touching letters from James Bradley and Kelly’s stateside tank commander Paul Campbell (for which I provide a partial transcription below) :

 

 

Dear Mr. Kasten,

I knew your uncle "Kelly" Woytasik real well. He was in my tank all the time we were in the states. He was my gunner. We had a 90mm part time but a 76 most of the time.

He was an excellent gunner and one of the finest people that I knew. A very good soldier. I was tank commander in a crew of 5 people. You can be real proud of him.

When we went to combat in Europe I was promoted to Platoon Sgt. and took over a different group of people.

I was wounded in the Battle of the Bulge and was in the hospital when Kelly was killed. I understand he was standing in the turret of the tank with a pair of field glasses looking for snipers and evidently the German saw the glare off the field glasses and fired at the glare striking Kelly in the forehead. ... probably never knew what happened.

 

It sure brings back a lot of memories when I think about it. I think he was married just before we left for overseas. I remember him introducing his wife to me at Camp Polk Louisiana. They sure were nice people. It's a shame what happened.

<...>

Paul Campbell

 

———————

 

Mr. Campbell’s description of the use of 76mm and 90mm guns seems unlikely. At the time of their training, the 76mm gun was only available on the M18 Hellcat (76mm Gun Motor Carriage M18) and the 90mm gun was installed on the M36 Pershing (90mm Gun Motor Carriage M26). Further research into when either of these entered into training is needed. 

 

———————

 

 

I was greatly humbled to be invited to the reunion of the 2nd Tank Battalion. I met some wonderful people including the aforementioned Barb Boese as well as Alex and John.

 

Here is Alex Bisterfeldt and a youthful version of myself on September 18th, 1998.  Note Alex's 9th Armored Division pin on his left lapel.  The unit gave me one of these lapel pins as well and I have worn as a memorial on my winter jackets ever since that day. 

 

Upon our initial handshake Alex teared-up a bit and was obviously recollecting some sad memories. But ultimately, he was very happy to see a member of Kelly’s family. From the letters above, one can see that he was close to Kelly and was deeply troubled by his loss. 

 

I maintained mail contact with Alex after the reunion. But I greatly regret not going to visit him. Alex was a wonderful individual. 

 

Alex passed away on Feb 21, 2011:

 

Alex Fredrick Bisterfeldt, age 90, died Monday, Feb. 21, 2011, at the Hays Good Samaritan Center, Hays. He was born May 21, 1920, in rural Ellsworth County to Carl and Dorothea (Funk) Bisterfeldt. He married Theresa (Short) on Oct. 26, 1946, at Hays. She died Sept 9, 2000.

 

He was a veteran of the U.S. Army and served during WW II. He attended school North of Holyrood, and then joined the Army in 1939. Then he attended High School in Camp Polk in Leesville, La., in 1942. In the Army he served in the Second Tank Battalion, Ninth Armored Division, European Theatre of Operation, including the Battle of The Bulge. He also acted as an interpreter for captured German soldiers. He received the Bronze Star, The Presidential Unit Citation and the French Croix de Guerre.

 

He was a heavy-duty mechanic in Civil Service on a Military Base in Barstow, Calif., for about 35 years. He lived in Great Bend, Pratt and moved to Hays Good Samaritan Center in 2009. He was a member of the Church of Christ.

 

 

Here is the headstone picture of Alex and his wife Theresa in what one might guess to be perhaps around 1970. Note his lapel pin—it is his Bronze Star medal ribbon. After surviving Task Force Rose, Team Pyle, the siege of Bastogne, and then the battle at the Remagen bridge, Alex was a true war hero tank commander. 

 

 


Here is Kelly’s photo at what I presume is outside of the recruitment office in Milwaukee in October 1942 along with his recruitment studio photo (replete with photo retouching of that era):

 

These are from desert “Tank School” training at (what was then) Camp Ibis in California (about 100mi south of Las Vegas just west of Highway 95) where the 9th Armored Division trained from June 1943 through September 1943. One item of note here is the “D" company marking on the back of the tank. It is possible that Kelly was moved from “D” company to “A” company at some point. According to Baird and Reichelt, these tanks were not their assigned tanks - those were left at Camp Funston in Kansas. These tanks were dedicated to training and stayed at Camp Ibis. In addition, the leftmost picture shows the engine doors open, clearly revealing the Wright R-975 9-cylinder Radial engine used in the M4 and M4A1. The welded hull likely makes the tank depicted below an M4. When the 9th Armored Division arrived in Europe they were assigned the Ford GAA V-8 (1,100 CID, 500bhp) powered M4A3(76)W with the 76mm main gun, with both VVSS and HVSS suspensions.

 

These were taken in front of the Waytasik family store and tavern in Bevent WI (sometime after recruitment, on leave). This building no longer exists in Bevent.

 

 

 

Pike Lake, WI (or perhaps Crooked Lake) in the background on the left, and the Woytasik family farm in Franzen, WI on the right:

 

 

A few more taken on the farm (in what was a DX station attendant or gas delivery uniform on the left)

 

 

 

(Likely) senior portrait (left); on the right is (likely) Uncle Kelly’s oldest sister Sarah and his Mom (my great Grandmother) Frances Woytasik and a young Kelly:

 

 

Uncle Kelly and his parents and siblings in about 1928. Kelly is in the front. His brothers Sam and Palmer left to right. His sisters Sarah, Leona (my Grandmother) and Regina from left to right. His parents (my great-grandparents) Frances and Michael Woytasik

 

 

Uncle Kelly and then-girlfriend Pauline Wisniewski in front of the family tavern in Bevent, WI, on leave, in what would have been after divisional assignment. 

 


Kelly's marriage to Pauline on July 31st, 1944 which is written on the photo itself. This is certainly on or near the base at Camp Polk in Louisiana, literally days before the 9th Armored division left Camp Polk for New Jersey to embark the Queen Mary to go overseas. Baird cites “early August” (1944) for their departure from Camp Polk to Camp Kilmer in New Jersey.

 

The front and back of a letter from then-Congressman Thad Wasielewski  - it may be Pauline’s or Grandma’s writing which dates Kelly's wedding to 31st of July 1944 at Camp Polk, LA.

 

 

Pauline passed away in 2011. Her family thoughtfully mentioned Clarence Woytasik in their obituary. Her obituary from the Thursday, May 26th, 2011 edition of the Steven’s Point Journal:

 

 

Thanks to Pauline's thoughtfulness, before passing away, she gave a number of the pictures above as well as Uncle Kelly’s medal back to Kelly’s sister Leona (my Grandma) in 2003:

 

 

 

I attempted to get a copy of Uncle Kelly’s service record. Of course, the fire at National Personnel Records Center in St. Louis in 1973 precluded my getting anything but the “Report of Death”.

 

 

The application for a military headstone signed by Uncle Kelly’s brother Sam Woytasik and dated 6 Oct 1950:

 

 

This is Uncle Kelly’s final resting place at St. Ladislaus Catholic Church Cemetery in Bevent, WI as it appeared in this photo I took on July 4, 2014:  

 

 

Kelly’s Service ribbons as they would appear on his uniform. In order from top-left-to-right and down - Purple Heart, Presidential Unit Citation, Good Conduct, American Campaign, European Campaign, WWII Victory. As part of CCR/9th he would have also received the Belgian Croix de Guerre with Palm.

 

 

In Feb 2015, my brother Joel was visiting Bill and Patsy Filtz (cousins of Uncle Kelly's) in Bevent WI regarding the purchase of an old delivery truck. As it turns out they knew Grandma’s brothers quite well and had several pictures of Kelly - including one I HAVE NEVER SEEN - taken at (as can be seen on the photo frame) a studio in Leesville, LA right outside of Camp Polk. The great thing is that this picture shows clearly his 9th Armored Division insignia. Patsy Filtz graciously gave this photograph to my brother. An incredible bit of serendipity. On the left is an SMS photo my brother Joel sent me on Feb 6, 2015, the day he first saw it, to my shock and amazement, and to the right is my high-resolution B&W scan of the same image.

 


Late October 2018 I received my November 2018 copy of "The Bulge Bugle" (the official publication of the "Battle of the Bulge Association"). Although it is for this very reason I belong to the association, I was happily astonished to see this request for information:



I contacted Mr. Morris - himself a former M1A1 Platoon Sergeant serving in Co B, 2nd Bn, of the 123rd Armored Regiment of the Kentucky Army National Guard. Currently he is a member of the U.S. Army Brotherhood of Tankers. They are interested in preserving the memory, heritage, and history of their fellow tankers. It is very reassuring to seem him, and his group interested in, and appreciating, Task Forces Rose and Harper. 

 

Mr. Morris forwarded me some incredible and invaluable information he collected through conversations and correspondence, all of which adds to our narrative and understanding of Uncle Kelly’s and all of Co A’s actions.

 

 

The first item is a particularly interesting correspondence from Mr. De Roche that disputes Baird – it was written in about 1999 (for which I provide a full transcription below). 


Late on Dec 17th, I was ordered to the junction of hwys 12 & 18 to block all enemy movement to the south. On the following morning when Captain Rose, who was supposed to have joined me, still had not shown, I was ordered to assume command. Phil Baird's "History of the Second Tank Battalion" has a rather inaccurate narration of the fighting on the 18th, but by evening I was backed up to the town of Lullange with the enemy to my front, my right and my rear. There was no enemy to my left, but I could occasionally hear distant firing from that side. After discussing my situation, Maj. Dalton asked me if he thought I could break out. I told him I could give it a go. He told me to go for it. 

 

I moved off to the left and eventually reached a road running generally to the northwest. I _nned up on that road and shortly afterward came upon a lone tank parked on the right side of the road. I stopped to see who it was. It was LTC Harper. I was puzzled as to why he was there alone when the battalion command section was south between Allerborn and Longvilly. I asked LTC Harper if he wanted to head the column. He told me to move on and he would fall in at the tail end of the column. 

 

Moving on I soon came to a town (Troine) and halted briefly to verify my location. I then resumed the movement, went to two subsequent towns (Buret and Tavigny) and finally reached Vissoule. As I reached the first buildings, I could just barely make out a roadblock in the dark consisting of farm carts. I told my driver to hit it hard and, as we broke through, we were hit with heavy but ineffective machine gun fire. I radioed to my company that the enemy had occupied the town and to spray both sides of the road with machine gun fire to keep the enemy pinned down. We cleared the town and a few kilometers further we reached Houffalize

 

A detachment from 82nd AB Div. was on its way up north and had stopped in the town on a break. I asked the OIC where I could pick up some supplies since my tanks were critically low on gas and also very low on ammunition. He thought we could get what we needed at Bastogne. 

 

I decided my men needed a bit of a break and at 4AM after a little more than 4 hours of rest we moved south on Hwy 26. Eventually we came to a traffic control point where I was informed that Bastogne had been captured (which it had not) but there was another supply point at St. Hubert. At St. Hubert I got my tanks fully gassed but there was no ammunition. I was told that Corps, which was at Neufchateau, could provide one with information as to where I could pick up ammunition. 

 

While my tank was being refueled, I walked down the line of tanks to see how everyone was doing. I was surprised to see five tanks were missing. Lt. Bob Linder, one of my officers who was in the last tank, said that LTC Harper had stopped them while the company was stopped in Troine and they were still there when the company moved on, when all the tanks were refueled we rolled on to Neufchateau where the ammunition was picked up. Because the road to Bastogne was covered by enemy fire, we waited until dark then moved up to Bastogne.

 

Lt. John Terral and Lt. Tom Wickey (an officer in my company) were with LTC Harper and his group. Lt. John Terral evaded capture, was evacuated when he was wounded in Bastogne, and returned to the company after the war. Lt. Wickey was captured and escaped, then found his way into Bastogne. He died three years ago.

 

Most of what I know about LTC Harper's death I got from Tom. According to Tom, LTC Harper led the tanks into Troine and gathered the vehicle commanders to decide what action should be taken. While the discussion was going on, an individual in an American uniform drove up. LTC Harper talked to him and, according to Tom, when he replied he didn't really have a German accent, but he didn't exactly sound like an American, and somebody said, "this bastard sounds like a kraut." With that, the would be American appeared to be reaching for a weapon and somebody shot him. LTC Harper then decided to move. They passed through two towns, and when they reached the third town, Vissoule, they ran into an ambush. I assume the enemy had been highly alerted as a result of our having shot up the place when we went through. All of the vehicles were lost, many of the men were shot, others evaded capture, and the rest, Tom concluded, were captured. Tom later escaped and found his way into Bastogne. Tom said it was total confusion. No one took control and it was every man for himself, and with everyone primarily concerned about not getting shot, there was no way anyone could have seen how LTC Harper got shot. Tom's opinion was that to say LTC Harper was killed by machine gun fire is an educated deduction.

 

 

This letter forwarded to me by Mr. Morris is particularly interesting as it is written by Company “A”, First Platoon commander John Terral. In this letter Mr. Terral is responding to Mr. Morris’ query in 2001 about Team Pyle. One of the more interesting items is his letter is the handwritten mention that the 14 tanks of Company “A” that survived to be used in Team Pyle action were M4A3E8s (HVSS). I find that hard to believe, but Mr. Terral would not likely be mistaken, and goes out of his way to mention it to Mr. Morris.

 

 

In a correspondence Mr. Morris obtained from a member of the Battle of the Bulge Association, Mr Terral mentions in his 2002 correspondence a number of interesting facts, including his rank and command of First Platoon of Company A. Mr. John Cobb Terral passed away on Oct 23, 2003. 

 

 

 

This M4A3(76)W served the 2nd Tank Battalion (Company “B”) and was the primary armored fighting vehicle used by 9th Armored Division as it sits to this day at a museum at the castle in Clervaux, Luxembourg - apparently very close to the location where it was knocked out defending against the German advance. Note the VVSS suspension and that this is not an M4A3E8 that LT Terral mentions Company “A" had. 

 

 

Sources copied, quoted and cited:

 

Baird, Philip J. “History of the 2nd Tank Battalion of the 9th Armored Division 1942-1945”. 1982

Cole, Dr. Hugh. “The Ardennes: Battle of the Bulge”. 1964

Dunnigan, James F. “Wacht am Rhein”. 1977

Dupuy, Trevor N., et al. “Hitler’s Last Gamble”. 1994

Hunnicutt, R.P. "Sherman: A History of the American Medium Tank". 1978

MacDonald, Charles. "A Time for Trumpets”. 1985

Reichelt, Dr. Walter. "Phantom Nine”. 1987

Stansell, Patrick and Laughlin, Kurt. “Son of Sherman Volume 1”. 2013 

Toland, John. “Battle: Story of the Bulge”. 1959

Tolhurst, Michael. “Bastogne: Battle of the Bulge”. 2001

Zaloga, Steven. “Armored Thunderbolt”. 2008

U.S. Army. “73rd Armored Field artillery Battalion AAR #366”

War Department. “TM 9-759 Technical Manual. TANK, MEDIUM M4A3”, 1944

 

The best secondary source for the 2nd Tank Battalion is Baird who was in S3 staff and was physically present for some described action herein.
 

Reichelt’s “Phantom Nine” is really the finest and most complete secondary treatment of the 9th Armored Division. It in particular has wonderfully detailed original maps. Unfortunately, it is currently out of print and a bit scarce.

Despite a number of errors about Task Force Rose, Cole is exceptionally detailed and is the standard and official U.S. Army secondary source on the entire offensive.

Toland and McDonald are well-written and enjoyable readings.

 

Dupuy is a superb treatment and analysis. He understood the primary material and paraphrased the TF Rose engagement with general correctness, stating that Co. A “maintained a determined resistance until after dark”.

AAR #366 is really necessary to help understand and align the timelines of TF Rose with 73rd AFA’s positions and fire missions on Dec. 18th and 19th.

 

For technical understanding of the M4 armored fighting vehicle, Steven Zaloga’s numerous Osprey publications on armor, and in particular his book on M4 development: “Armored Thunderbolt” are excellent. In addition, “Son of Sherman Volume 1” by Stansell and Laughlin and “Sherman: A History of the American Medium Tank" by Hunnicutt are good for very specific facts, with lots of pictures. The former is geared toward scale modelers, and the latter has been the standard for decades. 

 

There are a number of books and essays that cover the drive upon and defense of Bastogne - particularly books that include anecdotal or interview material. Anything involving the 2nd Tank Battalion will have to use Baird as a (the) primary official source. 

 

A particularly short but well-written and thoroughly researched introductory book on the Bastogne portion of the battle is Michael Tolhurst’s “Bastogne: Battle of the Bulge” which is part of the “Battleground Europe Series” published in the U.K. This series of books are geared toward use as a tourist handbook of the battlefield. Tolhurst clearly read and understood Baird and Reichelt. He mentions Lt. De Roche by name.

 

The book “Alamo in the Ardennes”, John C. McManus is a work that covers this action. In reviewing the portions where essentially all he did was transcribe Reichelt and Baird, he made a number of significant mistakes, indicating he didn’t fully comprehend the material. In his postscript he comments how CCR/9AD “never received a Distinguished Unit Citation”. That is an embarrassingly false statement. Avoid this book.

A noteworthy British television documentary called “A World at War” from 1973 is worth mentioning. For those that need a good introduction to WWII along with and its causes and outcomes, will find this narrative form of history fascinating. Many of the war’s participants were still alive and were interviewed. It is an outstanding and unusually unbiased work that has stood the test of time.

 

My former boss, author, military analyst, commentator, and the father of the modern conflict simulation, James F. Dunnigan, designed and published perhaps the foremost paper simulation of the entire Ardennes offensive at the battalion and company level. “Wacht am Rhein” published by his company SPI in 1977. This is in many ways the best way to truly comprehend a World War II battle at the operational level and particularly the logistics issues both sides faced.

 

Here is a happy clipping from the "Daily Press” newspaper (Newport News, Virginia) dated Sunday Oct 7, 1945:

 

---------

 

This memorial photo journal is dedicated to the everlasting memory of my grand uncle P.F.C. Clarence Frank Woytasik, his tank commander Sgt. Alex Frederick Bisterfeldt, First Platoon commander Lt. John Cobb Terral, Company “A” commander Lt. John Edward De Roche, and all of the very brave tankers of Company A of the 2nd Tank Battalion, attached to Combat Command Reserve of the 9th Armored Division of the U.S. Army. 

 

Your sacrifices will never be forgotten.

 

Robert B. Kasten 

bkasten@octavian.net